From 41a0d0d51686117c285dfe9acd70434826c061f7 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rae Lovejoy Date: Fri, 23 Oct 2026 23:03:48 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 1/7] docs: audit open PR dependencies and prepare the next review batch --- AUDIT.md | 65 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ROADMAP.md | 4 ++-- 2 files changed, 67 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/AUDIT.md b/AUDIT.md index bba6fe7..8b1c80e 100644 --- a/AUDIT.md +++ b/AUDIT.md @@ -306,3 +306,68 @@ This checkpoint supersedes the remaining-publication statements in the preceding [Root #46](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/46), [organization profile/registry #10](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/.github/pull/10), [Wiki build/visibility #15](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/wiki/pull/15), and [root status follow-up #51](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/51) are merged. The public website, repository introductions, organization profile and registry, seven-public-repository Wiki projection, and corrected private/revision status for Liberated Intelligence and Liberation Mass are now on their default branches. The released documentation preserves project-local authority, research/evidence limits, private-source boundaries, and the separation of work-sample review. It does not adopt research claims, governance proposals, licensing changes, or private-Wiki material. The next planned professional-refresh action is the evidence-based open-PR triage in ROADMAP P1-12. + +## Open-PR triage: 2026-10-23 + +Dates in this section use Pacific time. Root #52 is merged as `f42d934a05d1783ee003d3fd9b8f23545a39a30a`, completing the publication-status follow-up. The next work is the existing PR backlog, not another publication receipt. + +The live inventory contains **32 open PRs across 15 repositories: 16 public and 16 private**. Every PR has an initial recommendation. This public record covers the public proposals; private titles, branch contents, and findings remain in a private local handoff. No PR was merged or closed during the audit. No open proposal was found to be wholly superseded and ready for closure on that basis alone. + +### Progress and review depth + +| Check | Status | Evidence / remaining work | +| --- | --- | --- | +| [x] | done | Read current PR metadata, bodies, and changed-file inventories for all 32; read the small documentation diffs and selected scope, method, and boundary sections of the larger drafts. | +| [x] | done | Compare all 16 public PRs with current main using local Git tree merges; repair the sole current-main conflict in existing root #43. | +| [x] | done | Check all 21 pairs of the seven root research/proposal PRs after projecting each onto current main. Two pairs conflict, recorded below. | +| [x] | done | Prepare three existing maintenance PRs for individual review, preserve current privacy labels, and verify their exact remote commit trees. | +| [ ] | to do | Complete deeper source/claim review of root #44/#45, publication-policy review of #50, and separate technical review of the larger private drafts. This triage is not those reviews. | +| [ ] | to do | Decide each merge or closure individually, then reconcile accepted source proposals and their companions. No bulk merge is proposed. | + +Full papers, generated PDFs, every external source, and private runtime behavior were not independently validated here. Checks reported in older PR descriptions remain their authors' records unless explicitly rerun below. A clean Git merge establishes textual compatibility, not evidence quality or approval. P1-12 therefore remains **in progress** in the canonical checklist. + +### First maintenance candidates + +1. **[Organization #13](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/.github/pull/13)** corrects the published profile/Wiki status in two context files and removes the stale pending-publication sentence from the infrastructure README. The branch now changes three documentation files. Profile copy, project registry, and policies are unchanged. +2. **[Organization #5](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/.github/pull/5)** adds the already-public Commons of Inquiry bootstrap under `external_or_nested_projects`. Its actual source is [`incubator/commons-of-inquiry/README.md`](incubator/commons-of-inquiry/README.md). The record retains `canonical_home: pending`, distinguishes the current nested seed from an intended standalone repository, and does not claim an operating institution. Current main is incorporated; all existing project records remain identical to main, including private/revision labels. +3. **[Wiki #12](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/wiki/pull/12)** adds one working Existential Euphoria identity and two index routes, grounded in its public repository and the organization registry. Original reflection and AI-assisted interpretation remain distinct; historical phrase provenance is unverified. The project creation timestamp is September 28 in Pacific time, not a first-use claim. Current Wiki main is incorporated and a generated-site project-index link is repaired. This supersedes the already closed Wiki #11, not another open PR. + +Validation: organization registry YAML parses and its only proposed addition is the public seed. Wiki #12 passes the public/private boundary checker and MkDocs 1.6.1 strict build after source generation, with **36 canonical entities and 15 project lenses**. Its seven-public-repository automatic registry and private-project context labels are unchanged from current main. GitHub reports each candidate mergeable; their new heads have no posted reviews or check runs in this snapshot. GitHub's empty commit-status collection is not evidence of a queued or passing review. The local checks above are the evidence available for these small changes. + +### Public PR recommendations + +These are recommendations for review, not publication authorizations. Heads are the exact versions checked after the repairs in this pass. + +| PR | Checked head | Recommendation and reason | +| --- | --- | --- | +| [Organization #13](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/.github/pull/13) | `e7d6c6f6c30b2d4f47e9de3cf76fab373250c3e8` | First maintenance batch. Three context/introduction corrections now agree with published main. Remains draft for review. | +| [Organization #5](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/.github/pull/5) | `7cd6cae1b6b4e43850e73b912c4a8e66c8437afb` | First maintenance batch. Indexes an existing public seed without promoting it to an established institution. | +| [Wiki #12](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/wiki/pull/12) | `4d76d8e03bc1b32139f6e6b6b152427b29ca8ad2` | First maintenance batch. Source comparison and strict build pass; unfinished provenance remains explicit. Remains draft. | +| [Root #43](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/43) | `d4aec95fa138a2cb245dd76110a43b38dc34cc11` | Keep draft for author review of the collaboration proposal. README conflict repaired; reviewed main introduction/reuse wording and current privacy labels retained. Original substantive commons text unchanged. Its new main anchor is not available until acceptance. | +| [Organization #9](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/.github/pull/9) | `36527befd9f1f5576966940e9b57ef7aa194167f` | Keep draft. Depends on root #43's missing main anchor and needs local review of contribution/stewardship guidance. Its profile overlap was already removed; the remaining guidance is not redundant with merged #10. | +| [UCF #9](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/universal-coherence-framework/pull/9) | `817863e9e1612d85d4317b110f2e434bc2242819` | Keep draft with #43. Proposed contribution practices do not validate the model or establish operating governance. | +| [Discussions #8](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence-discussions/pull/8) | `1af04f3a59ae5aac2ef0cbaf73ed8a0d78e4f624` | Keep draft with #43; review moderation, dissent, and voluntary repair locally before adopting them. No new appeals body is established. | +| [Being Human(e) #6](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/beinghumane-guide/pull/6) | `a98959245c90583f4623ca1aba430634ab59abc3` | Keep draft with #43; preserve personal-story permissions and project-local contribution decisions. | +| [Wiki #13](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/wiki/pull/13) | `041842b66b1bbb70b04b24be25dfb87675963329` | Keep draft with #43. A README pointer, not a private-content import or a replacement for the substantive source. | +| [Root #50](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/50) | `8590f16c6bf8ea2fd010f9fe27be9b53006823a9` | Keep draft for publication-policy, attribution, and licensing decisions. Guidance explicitly remains proposed. Preserve existing grants; the October 22 license audit is dated history, not a current public-access census. Review its complete decision checklist before adoption. | +| [Organization #12](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/.github/pull/12) | `20fe610c6bb7306c49fdef107443a800f3afd303` | Keep paired with #50. Links deliberately pin the proposal's exact revision and describe it as unadopted; review those targets again if #50 changes. | +| [Root #41](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/41) | `c731d2f481c86eef4bbcba32290be5b1a803e493` | Small next content-review candidate. Adds representational-legibility distinctions in two existing concepts; no formal metric or empirical validation follows from the wording. | +| [Root #40](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/40) | `0cf7ed00cd241f083510c605a7dfe7fbc48554f6` | Author review of anticipation/surprise wording, followed by reconciliation with #42. Non-draft status does not establish accepted content or validated mechanisms. | +| [Root #42](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/42) | `6329bfea8b9d25a3bf5845046f3313f17d063b57` | Keep draft for source and translation review of agency under stress. New source page is absent from main; companion pointers require a source decision. Reconcile design-grammar wording with #40. | +| [Root #44](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/44) | `00f14ffd8fb8bffc0c551e1bab88b64c1f5c58b2` | Keep draft. Large research map and analytical probes require claim-level reading and source checks. Stipulated probabilities and mathematical toys are not human/organizational experiments or proof of an RS diagnostic advantage. Reconcile its index with #45. | +| [Root #45](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/45) | `30748ee8db9bfde29fc0312a41b8f04edd98340d` | Keep draft. The Stoned Age has substantial reader editions and a source/claims ledger, but author, scholarly, cultural, and accessibility review remain incomplete. Existing validation records are not rerun scientific appraisal. Reconcile its research index with #44; website publication remains separate. | + +### Dependencies and overlap + +The five public companions to #43 are organization #9, UCF #9, Discussions #8, Being Human(e) #6, and Wiki #13. Their links to `commons/README.md#collaboration-as-a-living-experiment` will resolve on main only after a source decision. Accepting a shared proposal would still not approve every project's adaptation. Private companions retain their own review boundaries. + +All 16 public proposals now merge individually into the checked current main trees. The root #43 repair passes the reader-document checker for all **238 Markdown files**. Pairwise checks of the seven root proposals found two conflicts: + +- **#40 and #42:** `concepts/design-grammar.md`. Their prospective-guidance/agency wording needs a deliberate combined edit after deciding which content to accept. +- **#44 and #45:** `research/README.md`. Both insert research entries at the same place. Retain both only if each research proposal is accepted; no reason to copy one draft's substance into the other now. + +The other 19 root pairs merge textually without conflict. This is not a test of every multi-PR order or semantic consistency. In particular, #50's proposed stewardship guidance and #43's collaboration practices need substantive review even though their repaired trees combine cleanly. + +Checked public main revisions: root `f42d934a05d1783ee003d3fd9b8f23545a39a30a`; organization `7ea6c4b7cd191775a17d951935c7f9927f691f70`; Wiki `7b7d15120e289ab2798476afaf928f6a567c6172`; UCF `e1c7b28803f58bea4a5b3a200063d5f579260b50`; Discussions `e93ec409bf3f490dbce47ae242921a5ccb276b1e`; Being Human(e) `e7e8b35a7f13e15c041b53475a80aefbdb499437`; Existential Euphoria public source `eb306d4e83d06790c53b3b6f0a90db227b193fcd`. Refresh affected heads and main before an actual merge decision if they change. + +Recommended order: review the three maintenance candidates first, then the small #41 conceptual addition. Review #43 as a shared proposal before its companions. Keep the larger research and stewardship families separate so a documentation cleanup cannot silently adopt research conclusions, licensing choices, or new governance. diff --git a/ROADMAP.md b/ROADMAP.md index 065b55c..f4956f2 100644 --- a/ROADMAP.md +++ b/ROADMAP.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # Root Sequence professional refresh -**Canonical progress checklist · started 2026-10-17 · Public documentation batch complete · Open-PR triage next** +**Canonical progress checklist · started 2026-10-17 · Public documentation batch complete · Open-PR triage in progress** This plan improves the public introduction to Root Sequence as an independent interdisciplinary research initiative started by Rae Lovejoy. Its exploratory writing, technical questions, social inquiry, and speculative work remain part of the project. The [research method](research/method.md), [repository map](root_map.md), and [ecosystem map](ECOSYSTEM.md) retain their existing authority. @@ -36,7 +36,7 @@ This is the single checklist for this refresh. Project-specific backlogs remain | [x] | P1-05 | done | Rae explicitly approved website publication on 2026-10-19 (UTC). [Website-only PR #47](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/47) merged as `b179a7fa56252dfd9fefbb3f93dcf1a9e1dd3ec6`; [Pages run](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/actions/runs/39211072192) succeeded. Live HTTPS apex and www return the exact generated release. The approval record matches the reviewed source; the gate still rejects historical/stale approval. No other draft or research endorsement follows. | | [x] | P1-11 | done | The public-documentation batch is complete. [Root #46](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/46) merged as `ec9ba2f693d482450e2361cde01a9b010089a91e`; [profile #10](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/.github/pull/10) merged as `7ea6c4b7cd191775a17d951935c7f9927f691f70`; [Wiki #15](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/wiki/pull/15) merged as `7b7d15120e289ab2798476afaf928f6a567c6172`; and [status follow-up #51](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/51) merged as `c53f704202a6e8db150b9c77c761abfad54b5502`. The website, repository documentation, organization profile/registry, seven-public-repository Wiki snapshot, and privacy corrections for Liberated Intelligence and Liberation Mass are published. Unreviewed applicant exercises remain on `review/work-samples-2026-10-23` outside this release. Research, licensing, governance, and private-Wiki changes were not adopted by the batch. | | [x] | P1-06 | done | Repair the 15 existing reader-check failures: correct one relative link and connect fourteen existing T-003 supporting records from their current open-questions section. The checker now passes all 238 Markdown files. Paper findings, author review, and the independent-comparison boundary remain unchanged. | -| [ ] | P1-12 | to do | After P1-11, triage open PRs across Root Sequence against current main and their canonical homes. Read the diffs, check dependencies and overlap, and record a recommendation with evidence for each PR. Keep substantive research and governance proposals separate from routine maintenance. Merge and closure decisions remain individual review decisions; preserve superseded work before proposing closure. | +| [ ] | P1-12 | in progress | Initial triage covers all 32 open PRs: 16 public recommendations are in the [dated review](AUDIT.md#open-pr-triage-2026-10-23); 16 private recommendations remain in a private local handoff. Existing organization #13/#5 and Wiki #12 are refreshed and checked as the first maintenance candidates. Root #43's README conflict is repaired in its existing draft. All 16 public PRs are individually compatible with the checked main revisions; pairwise checks identify conflicts between root #40/#42 and #44/#45. Larger research and private implementation drafts still need deeper review. No PR is merged or closed by this pass, and no policy or research adoption is inferred. | ## P2: small applicant work-samples track From 516b15ae2c5307ccae2723b8c356c2e90fbbd61d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rae Lovejoy Date: Fri, 23 Oct 2026 23:04:14 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 2/7] docs: make the pre-report PR inventory boundary explicit --- AUDIT.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/AUDIT.md b/AUDIT.md index 8b1c80e..b7cbe21 100644 --- a/AUDIT.md +++ b/AUDIT.md @@ -311,7 +311,7 @@ The released documentation preserves project-local authority, research/evidence Dates in this section use Pacific time. Root #52 is merged as `f42d934a05d1783ee003d3fd9b8f23545a39a30a`, completing the publication-status follow-up. The next work is the existing PR backlog, not another publication receipt. -The live inventory contains **32 open PRs across 15 repositories: 16 public and 16 private**. Every PR has an initial recommendation. This public record covers the public proposals; private titles, branch contents, and findings remain in a private local handoff. No PR was merged or closed during the audit. No open proposal was found to be wholly superseded and ready for closure on that basis alone. +The inventory taken before opening this audit PR contains **32 open PRs across 15 repositories: 16 public and 16 private**. Every PR has an initial recommendation. This public record covers the public proposals; private titles, branch contents, and findings remain in a private local handoff. No PR was merged or closed during the audit. No open proposal was found to be wholly superseded and ready for closure on that basis alone. ### Progress and review depth From 241ec43ed5a1016345ab014d75c87a42f54164ef Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rae Lovejoy Date: Fri, 23 Oct 2026 23:16:21 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 3/7] docs: record merged maintenance and scoped legibility review --- AUDIT.md | 24 +++++++++++++++++++++++- ROADMAP.md | 2 +- 2 files changed, 24 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/AUDIT.md b/AUDIT.md index b7cbe21..4f179a0 100644 --- a/AUDIT.md +++ b/AUDIT.md @@ -351,7 +351,7 @@ These are recommendations for review, not publication authorizations. Heads are | [Wiki #13](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/wiki/pull/13) | `041842b66b1bbb70b04b24be25dfb87675963329` | Keep draft with #43. A README pointer, not a private-content import or a replacement for the substantive source. | | [Root #50](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/50) | `8590f16c6bf8ea2fd010f9fe27be9b53006823a9` | Keep draft for publication-policy, attribution, and licensing decisions. Guidance explicitly remains proposed. Preserve existing grants; the October 22 license audit is dated history, not a current public-access census. Review its complete decision checklist before adoption. | | [Organization #12](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/.github/pull/12) | `20fe610c6bb7306c49fdef107443a800f3afd303` | Keep paired with #50. Links deliberately pin the proposal's exact revision and describe it as unadopted; review those targets again if #50 changes. | -| [Root #41](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/41) | `c731d2f481c86eef4bbcba32290be5b1a803e493` | Small next content-review candidate. Adds representational-legibility distinctions in two existing concepts; no formal metric or empirical validation follows from the wording. | +| [Root #41](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/41) | `8a6c7b0e9bcbcb24ba725500ffd6e132338dc530` | Scoped review complete; author's content decision next. Original 36-line proposal is unchanged and current main is incorporated. Working design distinctions, not formal metrics or empirical validation. See the later checkpoint below. | | [Root #40](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/40) | `0cf7ed00cd241f083510c605a7dfe7fbc48554f6` | Author review of anticipation/surprise wording, followed by reconciliation with #42. Non-draft status does not establish accepted content or validated mechanisms. | | [Root #42](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/42) | `6329bfea8b9d25a3bf5845046f3313f17d063b57` | Keep draft for source and translation review of agency under stress. New source page is absent from main; companion pointers require a source decision. Reconcile design-grammar wording with #40. | | [Root #44](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/44) | `00f14ffd8fb8bffc0c551e1bab88b64c1f5c58b2` | Keep draft. Large research map and analytical probes require claim-level reading and source checks. Stipulated probabilities and mathematical toys are not human/organizational experiments or proof of an RS diagnostic advantage. Reconcile its index with #45. | @@ -371,3 +371,25 @@ The other 19 root pairs merge textually without conflict. This is not a test of Checked public main revisions: root `f42d934a05d1783ee003d3fd9b8f23545a39a30a`; organization `7ea6c4b7cd191775a17d951935c7f9927f691f70`; Wiki `7b7d15120e289ab2798476afaf928f6a567c6172`; UCF `e1c7b28803f58bea4a5b3a200063d5f579260b50`; Discussions `e93ec409bf3f490dbce47ae242921a5ccb276b1e`; Being Human(e) `e7e8b35a7f13e15c041b53475a80aefbdb499437`; Existential Euphoria public source `eb306d4e83d06790c53b3b6f0a90db227b193fcd`. Refresh affected heads and main before an actual merge decision if they change. Recommended order: review the three maintenance candidates first, then the small #41 conceptual addition. Review #43 as a shared proposal before its companions. Keep the larger research and stewardship families separate so a documentation cleanup cannot silently adopt research conclusions, licensing choices, or new governance. + +## Maintenance merges and legibility review: 2026-10-23 + +This checkpoint supersedes the pending status of the three maintenance candidates above. Dates use Pacific time. Rae merged organization #13 and #5, followed by Wiki #12. All seven affected published files match the reviewed candidate blobs exactly. + +| Completed PR | Merge commit | Verified result | +| --- | --- | --- | +| [Organization #13](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/.github/pull/13) | `9880ad1186fa436f70cc152ece60ee064bc37442` | Infrastructure README and both context files describe the completed profile/Wiki publication consistently. | +| [Organization #5](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/.github/pull/5) | `2ac252195775efcef42506027e033c5e84e99fab` | Registry routes to the actual public commons bootstrap, with canonical home pending and no operating institution claimed. | +| [Wiki #12](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/wiki/pull/12) | `446a1294a309051b9bb1590ea459e8d8a343cd0c` | Existential Euphoria identity and index routes are published; provenance and AI-interpretation limits remain. | + +Wiki [deployment run 40069319901](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/wiki/actions/runs/40069319901) succeeded for the exact merge commit. The live [entity](https://wiki.rootsequence.systems/entities/existential-euphoria/), [project index](https://wiki.rootsequence.systems/projects/), [lexicon](https://wiki.rootsequence.systems/lexicon/), and [automatic registry](https://wiki.rootsequence.systems/auto-projects/) all return HTTP 200. The new identity and both index routes render; the entity keeps historical provenance unresolved and distinguishes AI interpretation from the original reflection. The automatic registry still contains no reading links to Liberated Intelligence or Liberation Mass. No private source was imported. + +### Next content decision: root #41 + +The complete two-file context and proposed additions in [#41](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/41) were read. The proposal distinguishes whether a structure holds together from whether another person can reconstruct it, then asks what a shorter representation preserves or loses. It explicitly avoids treating internal coherence as correctness or legitimacy. The distinctions remain working design guidance, not measured constructs. The AI-assisted-expression application retains its existing authorship, review, and privacy limits. + +The existing branch now incorporates current main `f42d934a05d1783ee003d3fd9b8f23545a39a30a`, at head `8a6c7b0e9bcbcb24ba725500ffd6e132338dc530`. Both proposed source files remain byte-for-byte identical to the original #41 head: exactly **36 added lines in two existing concept pages** relative to current main. No site copy, source claims, external citations, project adaptations, or other draft research is added. + +Validation: all 238 reader-document files pass; the whitespace check against current main passes; the new relative link and `representational-legibility` fragment resolve; both current evidence/status introductions are retained. No blocking issue was identified within this scope. This is not scientific or usability validation, an independent review, or the author's approval. #41 remains draft for a content decision. The agent did not merge or close any PR. + +The canonical P1-12 remains in progress. This completed maintenance batch and small content review do not finish deeper research, stewardship, private implementation, or Wiki-freshness review. Existing audit draft #53 is reused for this record; no additional tracking PR is created. diff --git a/ROADMAP.md b/ROADMAP.md index f4956f2..0be0669 100644 --- a/ROADMAP.md +++ b/ROADMAP.md @@ -36,7 +36,7 @@ This is the single checklist for this refresh. Project-specific backlogs remain | [x] | P1-05 | done | Rae explicitly approved website publication on 2026-10-19 (UTC). [Website-only PR #47](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/47) merged as `b179a7fa56252dfd9fefbb3f93dcf1a9e1dd3ec6`; [Pages run](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/actions/runs/39211072192) succeeded. Live HTTPS apex and www return the exact generated release. The approval record matches the reviewed source; the gate still rejects historical/stale approval. No other draft or research endorsement follows. | | [x] | P1-11 | done | The public-documentation batch is complete. [Root #46](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/46) merged as `ec9ba2f693d482450e2361cde01a9b010089a91e`; [profile #10](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/.github/pull/10) merged as `7ea6c4b7cd191775a17d951935c7f9927f691f70`; [Wiki #15](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/wiki/pull/15) merged as `7b7d15120e289ab2798476afaf928f6a567c6172`; and [status follow-up #51](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/51) merged as `c53f704202a6e8db150b9c77c761abfad54b5502`. The website, repository documentation, organization profile/registry, seven-public-repository Wiki snapshot, and privacy corrections for Liberated Intelligence and Liberation Mass are published. Unreviewed applicant exercises remain on `review/work-samples-2026-10-23` outside this release. Research, licensing, governance, and private-Wiki changes were not adopted by the batch. | | [x] | P1-06 | done | Repair the 15 existing reader-check failures: correct one relative link and connect fourteen existing T-003 supporting records from their current open-questions section. The checker now passes all 238 Markdown files. Paper findings, author review, and the independent-comparison boundary remain unchanged. | -| [ ] | P1-12 | in progress | Initial triage covers all 32 open PRs: 16 public recommendations are in the [dated review](AUDIT.md#open-pr-triage-2026-10-23); 16 private recommendations remain in a private local handoff. Existing organization #13/#5 and Wiki #12 are refreshed and checked as the first maintenance candidates. Root #43's README conflict is repaired in its existing draft. All 16 public PRs are individually compatible with the checked main revisions; pairwise checks identify conflicts between root #40/#42 and #44/#45. Larger research and private implementation drafts still need deeper review. No PR is merged or closed by this pass, and no policy or research adoption is inferred. | +| [ ] | P1-12 | in progress | Initial triage covers the 32-PR starting inventory: 16 public recommendations are in the [dated review](AUDIT.md#open-pr-triage-2026-10-23); 16 private recommendations remain in a private local handoff. Rae merged organization #13/#5 and Wiki #12; exact published source and the live Wiki update are verified. Root #41 has completed scoped review and current-main reconciliation in its existing draft; its content decision is next. Root #43's README conflict is repaired. Pairwise checks identify conflicts between root #40/#42 and #44/#45. Larger research and private implementation drafts still need deeper review. See the [maintenance and #41 checkpoint](AUDIT.md#maintenance-merges-and-legibility-review-2026-10-23). Merge, closure, and policy/research adoption remain individual decisions. | ## P2: small applicant work-samples track From b123effd87c1d29deaddaf81e4fec92d035169e1 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rae Lovejoy Date: Fri, 23 Oct 2026 23:50:05 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 4/7] docs: require link-plan review before either personal page is edited --- AUDIT.md | 2 ++ ROADMAP.md | 2 +- 2 files changed, 3 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/AUDIT.md b/AUDIT.md index d8ee2f0..40513ef 100644 --- a/AUDIT.md +++ b/AUDIT.md @@ -433,3 +433,5 @@ The next decision is publication of these proposed local applications and the Wi Rae requested adding a small [whoami](https://raearea.net/whoami/) project-ecology/link update to the work list. The canonical checklist records this as P4-01, to do, after the current public PR batch. A preliminary live read returned HTTP 200 and found a direct Liberation Mass repository link that now leads to a private project. Other destinations and the site's actual source/open drafts still need inspection before preparing an edit. No personal-site source, copy, deployment, or settings changed here. Existing audit #53 incorporates the #43 main merge and records this checkpoint. P1-12 remains in progress; P4-01 adds one queued task. No new PR, agent-performed merge or closure, role assignment, policy adoption, license change, or private-source export is included. + +Rae subsequently expanded P4-01 to include homepage links and explicitly requested the proposed changes before either personal page is edited. A read-only inventory of both pages, destination checks, and inspection of the actual public `raelovejoy/raearea` source produced a local keep/change/add/pending proposal. P4-01 remains to do pending that review; neither personal page nor its source has been edited. The detailed link decisions remain in the local proposal rather than becoming unapproved website changes. diff --git a/ROADMAP.md b/ROADMAP.md index 418dd61..082f09c 100644 --- a/ROADMAP.md +++ b/ROADMAP.md @@ -68,7 +68,7 @@ Queued after the current public PR batch; this small pass can precede the larger | Check | ID | Status | Deliverable and evidence | | --- | --- | --- | --- | -| [ ] | P4-01 | to do | Review the project-ecology wording and other links on [raearea.net/whoami](https://raearea.net/whoami/). A preliminary live read found a direct link to the now-private Liberation Mass repository; other destinations still need checking. Audit the actual site source and existing drafts before editing, then prepare a small link/copy update for review in that source repository. Keep the personal page's voice and use public-safe destinations. Publication requires its own decision. | +| [ ] | P4-01 | to do | Review the project-ecology wording and links on both [raearea.net](https://raearea.net/) and [whoami](https://raearea.net/whoami/). **Show Rae the proposed link additions, replacements, removals, and any copy changes before editing either page.** The live link inventory and actual source were inspected; a detailed proposal is prepared locally for review. Source is `raelovejoy/raearea`: homepage `index.html`, canonical whoami copy `whoami/whoami.md`, generated `whoami/index.html`. Recheck main and open drafts after approval, then prepare only the approved changes on a branch. Preserve the personal page's voice; publication requires its own decision. | ## Approved mission wording From b9aeeaee1a6f6e5334632cd7b73ed935b21af48c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rae Lovejoy Date: Sat, 24 Oct 2026 00:02:25 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 5/7] docs: record anticipation review and resolve draft overlap status --- AUDIT.md | 26 ++++++++++++++++++++++++-- ROADMAP.md | 2 +- 2 files changed, 25 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/AUDIT.md b/AUDIT.md index 40513ef..aaf2413 100644 --- a/AUDIT.md +++ b/AUDIT.md @@ -352,8 +352,8 @@ These are recommendations for review, not publication authorizations. Heads are | [Root #50](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/50) | `8590f16c6bf8ea2fd010f9fe27be9b53006823a9` | Keep draft for publication-policy, attribution, and licensing decisions. Guidance explicitly remains proposed. Preserve existing grants; the October 22 license audit is dated history, not a current public-access census. Review its complete decision checklist before adoption. | | [Organization #12](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/.github/pull/12) | `20fe610c6bb7306c49fdef107443a800f3afd303` | Keep paired with #50. Links deliberately pin the proposal's exact revision and describe it as unadopted; review those targets again if #50 changes. | | [Root #41](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/41) | `8a6c7b0e9bcbcb24ba725500ffd6e132338dc530` | Merged by Rae as `7c7231b9edc9b1d922fbbfd4a050f924b3823a1c`; exact published source verified. Working design distinctions, not formal metrics or empirical validation. See the later checkpoint below. | -| [Root #40](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/40) | `0cf7ed00cd241f083510c605a7dfe7fbc48554f6` | Author review of anticipation/surprise wording, followed by reconciliation with #42. Non-draft status does not establish accepted content or validated mechanisms. | -| [Root #42](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/42) | `6329bfea8b9d25a3bf5845046f3313f17d063b57` | Keep draft for source and translation review of agency under stress. New source page is absent from main; companion pointers require a source decision. Reconcile design-grammar wording with #40. | +| [Root #40](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/40) | `b14ee22016bf9890715ba78e48b819759830f054` | Scoped review complete; author's content decision next. Anticipation remains proposed design guidance. Current main, source-route repair, and explicit inspection limits are included; shared metadata conflict with #42 is resolved. | +| [Root #42](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/42) | `63d0d615000233dd1997869986195656ef1cc649` | Keep draft for source/domain and translation review of agency under stress. Current main and shared metadata are reconciled; original research/resilience wording unchanged. Source page is still absent from main. | | [Root #44](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/44) | `00f14ffd8fb8bffc0c551e1bab88b64c1f5c58b2` | Keep draft. Large research map and analytical probes require claim-level reading and source checks. Stipulated probabilities and mathematical toys are not human/organizational experiments or proof of an RS diagnostic advantage. Reconcile its index with #45. | | [Root #45](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/45) | `30748ee8db9bfde29fc0312a41b8f04edd98340d` | Keep draft. The Stoned Age has substantial reader editions and a source/claims ledger, but author, scholarly, cultural, and accessibility review remain incomplete. Existing validation records are not rerun scientific appraisal. Reconcile its research index with #44; website publication remains separate. | @@ -435,3 +435,25 @@ Rae requested adding a small [whoami](https://raearea.net/whoami/) project-ecolo Existing audit #53 incorporates the #43 main merge and records this checkpoint. P1-12 remains in progress; P4-01 adds one queued task. No new PR, agent-performed merge or closure, role assignment, policy adoption, license change, or private-source export is included. Rae subsequently expanded P4-01 to include homepage links and explicitly requested the proposed changes before either personal page is edited. A read-only inventory of both pages, destination checks, and inspection of the actual public `raelovejoy/raearea` source produced a local keep/change/add/pending proposal. P4-01 remains to do pending that review; neither personal page nor its source has been edited. The detailed link decisions remain in the local proposal rather than becoming unapproved website changes. + +## Anticipation review and draft overlap resolved: 2026-10-23 + +This checkpoint supersedes the unresolved #40/#42 conflict recorded in the initial pairwise audit. The five public commons companions and audit #53 remain open at the checked snapshot; no further merge is inferred from a request to continue. + +### Root #40: anticipation and surprise + +The full proposed diff and relevant design-grammar, dynamic-coherence, adaptation, resilience, and source-lineage context were reviewed. Its prompt, “Anticipate what you can. Design for what you can't,” asks designers to consider foreseeable effects while retaining ways to notice a mistaken model and recover. It preserves the distinction between preparation and authority, names brittle over-anticipation as a failure mode, and leaves project-specific implementation/canon decisions local. It remains an AI-assisted proposal awaiting author review, with no new empirical result or universal mechanism established. + +The existing branch now incorporates current main `95f6b73af47a4eb3e75ba3f0829e692af526bb11`, at head `b14ee22016bf9890715ba78e48b819759830f054`. Four original proposal files remain, plus a focused source repair in the existing `research/dynamic-coherence-lineage.md`. Reviewed main introduction, reuse, #41, #43, and private-project status are retained. + +The old Hollnagel author-site route no longer supplied the cited material. The [Resilience Engineering Institute overview](https://resilienceengineeringinstitute.org/resilience-analysis-grid/) was inspected for its account of the four potentials and method orientation. The [Woods publisher abstract and bibliographic record](https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10669-018-9708-3) were inspected for graceful extensibility and sustained adaptability. Neither the full technical note nor the full article was read in this pass. The lineage note now states that scope and labels the stronger claim about an intervention changing later conditions as a Root Sequence interpretation. The two anticipation sections link to that existing lineage treatment instead of leaving the comparison untraceable. No claim of full literature appraisal is added. + +Validation on #40: all 238 reader-document files pass; Idea Trail graph/index is valid and current; scoped whitespace and all 11 site checks pass. No blocking issue was identified within this scope. These checks do not complete author review, validate the design prompt, or approve its project-local applications. + +### Reconciliation with #42 + +The conflicting portions were the shared revision-date header and one long source-note paragraph. Both branches now separate pending-review status from dated source additions. #40's existing October 1 addition is recorded under change history; #42 retains its October 5 source addition. The refreshed #42 head is `63d0d615000233dd1997869986195656ef1cc649`, incorporating the same current main. Its agency-under-stress research and resilience source are byte-for-byte unchanged from the original proposal. No anticipation content is imported into #42, and no agency-under-stress content is imported into #40. + +A targeted tree check now combines #40/#42 cleanly and retains both separate table additions in the combined fixture. #40/#44 also combines cleanly despite the scoped lineage-reference repair. These are local compatibility checks, not merges or acceptance. #42 passes all 239 reader-document files, the graph/index check, and all 11 site checks; it remains draft pending deeper source/domain review and the author's decision. #44/#45's separate research-index conflict remains unresolved. + +Existing audit #53 records this work; P1-12 stays in progress. The personal-site link proposal remains pending review, including the supplied corrected Mastodon URL. Neither personal page was edited. No new PR, agent-performed merge/closure, deployment, clinical guidance approval, policy adoption, or private-source export is included. diff --git a/ROADMAP.md b/ROADMAP.md index 082f09c..f3be942 100644 --- a/ROADMAP.md +++ b/ROADMAP.md @@ -36,7 +36,7 @@ This is the single checklist for this refresh. Project-specific backlogs remain | [x] | P1-05 | done | Rae explicitly approved website publication on 2026-10-19 (UTC). [Website-only PR #47](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/47) merged as `b179a7fa56252dfd9fefbb3f93dcf1a9e1dd3ec6`; [Pages run](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/actions/runs/39211072192) succeeded. Live HTTPS apex and www return the exact generated release. The approval record matches the reviewed source; the gate still rejects historical/stale approval. No other draft or research endorsement follows. | | [x] | P1-11 | done | The public-documentation batch is complete. [Root #46](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/46) merged as `ec9ba2f693d482450e2361cde01a9b010089a91e`; [profile #10](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/.github/pull/10) merged as `7ea6c4b7cd191775a17d951935c7f9927f691f70`; [Wiki #15](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/wiki/pull/15) merged as `7b7d15120e289ab2798476afaf928f6a567c6172`; and [status follow-up #51](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/51) merged as `c53f704202a6e8db150b9c77c761abfad54b5502`. The website, repository documentation, organization profile/registry, seven-public-repository Wiki snapshot, and privacy corrections for Liberated Intelligence and Liberation Mass are published. Unreviewed applicant exercises remain on `review/work-samples-2026-10-23` outside this release. Research, licensing, governance, and private-Wiki changes were not adopted by the batch. | | [x] | P1-06 | done | Repair the 15 existing reader-check failures: correct one relative link and connect fourteen existing T-003 supporting records from their current open-questions section. The checker now passes all 238 Markdown files. Paper findings, author review, and the independent-comparison boundary remain unchanged. | -| [ ] | P1-12 | in progress | Initial triage covers the 32-PR starting inventory: public recommendations are in the [dated review](AUDIT.md#open-pr-triage-2026-10-23); private recommendations remain in a private local handoff. Rae merged organization #13/#5, Wiki #12, and root #41/#43; published source is verified. The five public commons companions are refreshed and checked in their existing drafts, with proposed local guidance distinguished from rule adoption. See the [companion-review checkpoint](AUDIT.md#commons-source-published-and-public-companions-prepared-2026-10-23). Their publication decisions are next. Root #40/#42 and #44/#45 still have pairwise conflicts. Larger research and private implementation drafts need deeper review; merge, closure, and policy/research adoption remain individual decisions. | +| [ ] | P1-12 | in progress | Initial triage covers the 32-PR starting inventory; private findings remain in a private handoff. Published source for organization #13/#5, Wiki #12, and root #41/#43 is verified. Five public commons companions remain ready for review. Root #40 has completed scoped review; #40/#42's shared metadata conflict is resolved without mixing proposal content. #42's research review remains pending, and #44/#45 still conflict in the research index. See the [anticipation-review checkpoint](AUDIT.md#anticipation-review-and-draft-overlap-resolved-2026-10-23). Larger research, stewardship, and private implementation reviews remain; publication and adoption are individual decisions. | ## P2: small applicant work-samples track From 841c7a97eed4c22f8431a8d70b8dd74aca504759 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rae Lovejoy Date: Sat, 24 Oct 2026 15:18:12 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 6/7] Track proposed /stonedage/ publication and verified draft packaging --- AUDIT.md | 15 +++++++++++++++ ROADMAP.md | 9 +++++---- 2 files changed, 20 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/AUDIT.md b/AUDIT.md index 8fcafb5..d4cb9a9 100644 --- a/AUDIT.md +++ b/AUDIT.md @@ -521,3 +521,18 @@ Validation on #45: all 256 reader-document files pass, the Idea Trail graph/inde No blocking issue was found within this bounded source/edition/navigation check. Author review remains pending. Arad full text, relevant supplements and registration comparisons, deeper source appraisal, situated cultural scholarship and independent disciplinary review remain open. Publishing the repository draft would not make it a reviewed scholarly release. Website publication requires a separate destination and deployment decision. No dosing guidance, clinical intervention or human-participant work is authorized. Existing audit #53 incorporates #44 main and changes only this audit and the canonical checklist relative to main; it imports no unmerged #45 suite. Its reader check passes 246 Markdown files, with graph/index and all 11 site checks passing. The checklist now has one consistent current summary: 31 tasks, 24 done, six to do, one in progress, none blocked. P1-12 remains in progress. Five public commons companions retain their previously checked candidate status, not a fresh audit. Stewardship/licensing and private implementation work remain separate; personal-site changes still await Rae's review of the link proposal. No new PR, agent-performed merge or closure, deployment, policy adoption, credential access or private-source export is included. + + +## Proposed Stoned Age website route: 2026-10-24 + +Rae suggested adding the existing suite at `rootsequence.systems/stonedage/`. The actual Pages workflow and publisher were inspected first. They currently export only the homepage, so merging the earlier research suite alone would not create that route. A live check found the proposed route returns HTTP 404; the public build manifest still describes the approved single-page edition. + +Existing draft #45 now prepares the route at `08286d1eff9592ed7e5eb01e05d1510972effe86`, tree `30c26ad548640f6ede05b9b2ffb7db640f659ef4`. Its full delta from main is 47 files: the existing 40-file research package/index plus seven site/workflow files. The route is prepared for review, not published. The research source, AI provenance, evidence limits and unfinished author/scholarly/cultural review remain as described in the earlier checkpoint. + +The new combined publisher reads `research/the-stoned-age/` and exports 24 explicitly named reading files alongside the existing homepage. It adds the `/stonedage/` path, a return link, canonical addresses and robots metadata to generated research pages. PDFs and data downloads retain their source bytes. Other source links point to the existing GitHub branch in preview and main in release. No second maintained research copy, editable JSON source, build tools, unrelated research, private material or historical site is included in the hosting artifact. The original homepage source, original publisher and original approval are unchanged. + +The proposed Pages workflow runs both publisher test suites, builds the combined artifact and watches the inquiry for updates. A separate pending `site/stonedage-approval.json` binds the exact route publisher, workflow, reading files and named source records. Its reviewer and approval date remain unset. The release command rejects that record before producing output. Merging the proposed workflow without the matching hosting approval would leave deployment blocked. No publication approval is inferred from the suggestion to prepare this route. + +All 11 homepage tests and six added research-publication tests pass. The combined preview has eight HTML pages; all 192 local links/assets/fragments resolve. It preserves homepage bytes and both PDF files. The new return link reaches the unchanged homepage. The research landing page was inspected at desktop and 390 pixels without horizontal overflow or missing images; screenshots are in the local handoff and the viewport was restored. Reader documentation passes 256 Markdown files on #45, and the graph/index remains current. Scoped whitespace passes. The remote tree and exact publisher/workflow/approval readbacks match the staged candidate. No new scientific appraisal or full accessibility review is claimed by this hosting pass. + +P1-13 records this bounded follow-up as in progress until review and publication are resolved. The canonical checklist now has 32 tasks: 24 done, six to do, two in progress, none blocked. Existing audit #53 is reused and changes only AUDIT.md/ROADMAP.md against current main; it imports no unmerged research or publisher code. P1-12, the remaining stewardship/licensing reviews and the personal-page pre-edit approval boundary remain. No new PR, agent-performed merge or public deployment occurred. diff --git a/ROADMAP.md b/ROADMAP.md index fc97897..94a679d 100644 --- a/ROADMAP.md +++ b/ROADMAP.md @@ -36,7 +36,8 @@ This is the single checklist for this refresh. Project-specific backlogs remain | [x] | P1-05 | done | Rae explicitly approved website publication on 2026-10-19 (UTC). [Website-only PR #47](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/47) merged as `b179a7fa56252dfd9fefbb3f93dcf1a9e1dd3ec6`; [Pages run](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/actions/runs/39211072192) succeeded. Live HTTPS apex and www return the exact generated release. The approval record matches the reviewed source; the gate still rejects historical/stale approval. No other draft or research endorsement follows. | | [x] | P1-11 | done | The public-documentation batch is complete. [Root #46](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/46) merged as `ec9ba2f693d482450e2361cde01a9b010089a91e`; [profile #10](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/.github/pull/10) merged as `7ea6c4b7cd191775a17d951935c7f9927f691f70`; [Wiki #15](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/wiki/pull/15) merged as `7b7d15120e289ab2798476afaf928f6a567c6172`; and [status follow-up #51](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/51) merged as `c53f704202a6e8db150b9c77c761abfad54b5502`. The website, repository documentation, organization profile/registry, seven-public-repository Wiki snapshot, and privacy corrections for Liberated Intelligence and Liberation Mass are published. Unreviewed applicant exercises remain on `review/work-samples-2026-10-23` outside this release. Research, licensing, governance, and private-Wiki changes were not adopted by the batch. | | [x] | P1-06 | done | Repair the 15 existing reader-check failures: correct one relative link and connect fourteen existing T-003 supporting records from their current open-questions section. The checker now passes all 238 Markdown files. Paper findings, author review, and the independent-comparison boundary remain unchanged. | -| [ ] | P1-12 | in progress | Initial triage covers the 32-PR starting inventory; private findings remain in a private handoff. Published source for organization #13/#5, Wiki #12, and root #41/#43/#40/#42/#44 is verified. Five public commons companions remain previously checked review candidates. Root #45 now incorporates #44 and has completed a bounded source/edition/navigation pass at `12efef65ede19744ed1f43df01cb5ebbc1165e22`; author, scholarly and cultural review remain pending. See the [Stoned Age checkpoint](AUDIT.md#intelligence-research-published-and-stoned-age-reviewed-2026-10-24). Stewardship/licensing and private implementation reviews remain separate; publication and adoption are individual decisions. | +| [ ] | P1-12 | in progress | Initial triage covers the 32-PR starting inventory; private findings remain in a private handoff. Published source for organization #13/#5, Wiki #12, and root #41/#43/#40/#42/#44 is verified. Five public commons companions remain previously checked review candidates. Root #45 now incorporates #44 and has completed a bounded source/edition/navigation pass at `12efef65ede19744ed1f43df01cb5ebbc1165e22` (source/edition review), with the later route proposal tracked under P1-13; author, scholarly and cultural review remain pending. See the [Stoned Age checkpoint](AUDIT.md#intelligence-research-published-and-stoned-age-reviewed-2026-10-24). Stewardship/licensing and private implementation reviews remain separate; publication and adoption are individual decisions. | +| [ ] | P1-13 | in progress | Prepare and review the proposed `rootsequence.systems/stonedage/` route in existing [draft #45](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/45), now at `08286d1eff9592ed7e5eb01e05d1510972effe86`. The combined preview reuses the canonical editions, preserves the homepage, and passes 17 publisher tests and 192 local-target checks. Hosting approval remains unset; the release gate blocks deployment. See the [route checkpoint](AUDIT.md#proposed-stoned-age-website-route-2026-10-24). Review and publication remain pending. | ## P2: small applicant work-samples track @@ -143,10 +144,10 @@ On **2026-10-17 (Pacific)**, Rae accepted writing block `86204` by replying “b - [Published Wiki: merged PR #15](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/wiki/pull/15), including the build repair and current public/private routing. - [Published status follow-up: merged PR #51](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/51). - [Current audit and checklist draft: PR #53](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/53). Reuses this plan and the existing audit; no additional tracking PR. -- [The Stoned Age: review draft #45](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/45), reconciled with main through #44. Author, scholarly and cultural review remain pending. -- **Next supported review:** Rae reviews #45 as a labelled working inquiry. The larger stewardship/licensing family needs its own substantive pass. Work samples, private implementation and Wiki reconciliation remain separate; personal-page edits still require review of the existing link proposal. +- [The Stoned Age: review draft #45](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/45), reconciled with main through #44. Author, scholarly and cultural review remain pending; the proposed `/stonedage/` deployment has a separate pending approval. +- **Next supported review:** Rae reviews #45 as a labelled working inquiry and considers its proposed hosting route. The larger stewardship/licensing family needs its own substantive pass. Work samples, private implementation and Wiki reconciliation remain separate; personal-page edits still require review of the existing link proposal. -Current status: **24 done, 6 to do, 1 in progress, 0 blocked** across 31 tasks. P1-11 is complete; P1-12 open-PR triage is in progress. The public documentation baseline and subsequent root #41/#43/#40/#42/#44 source changes are published. The latest source/edition review is #45; its publication and the remaining project decisions are pending. +Current status: **24 done, 6 to do, 2 in progress, 0 blocked** across 32 tasks. P1-11 is complete; P1-12 open-PR triage is in progress. The public documentation baseline and subsequent root #41/#43/#40/#42/#44 source changes are published. The latest source/edition review is #45; P1-13 now tracks its proposed `/stonedage/` hosting route. Publication and the remaining project decisions are pending. ## Accepted name context and first related-project description From c757f88021c5ec9b06e885e8663d956a1c1cb968 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Rae Lovejoy Date: Sat, 24 Oct 2026 15:23:04 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 7/7] Record repository-only Stoned Age references and clarify provocation status --- AUDIT.md | 11 +++++++++++ ROADMAP.md | 2 +- 2 files changed, 12 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/AUDIT.md b/AUDIT.md index d4cb9a9..2a2d941 100644 --- a/AUDIT.md +++ b/AUDIT.md @@ -536,3 +536,14 @@ The proposed Pages workflow runs both publisher test suites, builds the combined All 11 homepage tests and six added research-publication tests pass. The combined preview has eight HTML pages; all 192 local links/assets/fragments resolve. It preserves homepage bytes and both PDF files. The new return link reaches the unchanged homepage. The research landing page was inspected at desktop and 390 pixels without horizontal overflow or missing images; screenshots are in the local handoff and the viewport was restored. Reader documentation passes 256 Markdown files on #45, and the graph/index remains current. Scoped whitespace passes. The remote tree and exact publisher/workflow/approval readbacks match the staged candidate. No new scientific appraisal or full accessibility review is claimed by this hosting pass. P1-13 records this bounded follow-up as in progress until review and publication are resolved. The canonical checklist now has 32 tasks: 24 done, six to do, two in progress, none blocked. Existing audit #53 is reused and changes only AUDIT.md/ROADMAP.md against current main; it imports no unmerged research or publisher code. P1-12, the remaining stewardship/licensing reviews and the personal-page pre-edit approval boundary remain. No new PR, agent-performed merge or public deployment occurred. + + +## Stoned Age repository references and companion clarification: 2026-10-24 + +Rae clarified that the Root Sequence homepage does not need a Stoned Age link; the proposed website should be referenced where the research lives. Existing draft #45 now records the planned, unpublished `/stonedage/` address in its research README and parent research index. The homepage is byte-for-byte identical to current main and contains no Stoned Age link. + +The current suite contains no separate “How Drugs Explain the Universe” companion text. Its prior “companion provocation” label implied an artifact that was not supplied. The maintained README, paper, booklet JSON and landing-page generator now use “working provocation,” preserving the phrase as framing for the inquiry. The generated editions and booklet cover preview were rebuilt. No separate companion was invented or added, and the evidence and review status remain. + +The existing #45 head is `2f382c71c1434f1c2ee447656aa5a1dffe2c57ef`, tree `e58ad9f63cc7c4c59552b0f2b68b036c316d1892`. The full delta remains 47 files against main. All 17 site/publisher tests, the 256-file reader check, graph/index and scoped whitespace pass. The changed cover was rendered and visually checked; text on the other 15 booklet pages is unchanged, and the talk PDF is byte-identical. The pending hosting fingerprint was refreshed without adding a reviewer or approval date. Exact remote research references and the pending record match the staged candidate. No publication is claimed. + +Existing audit #53 records the clarification and current P1-13 head without importing the suite. Its reader check passes 246 Markdown files. The checklist retains 32 tasks: 24 done, six to do, two in progress, none blocked. No new PR, agent-performed merge, public deployment, research conclusion or personal-page change is included. diff --git a/ROADMAP.md b/ROADMAP.md index 94a679d..409f85e 100644 --- a/ROADMAP.md +++ b/ROADMAP.md @@ -37,7 +37,7 @@ This is the single checklist for this refresh. Project-specific backlogs remain | [x] | P1-11 | done | The public-documentation batch is complete. [Root #46](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/46) merged as `ec9ba2f693d482450e2361cde01a9b010089a91e`; [profile #10](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/.github/pull/10) merged as `7ea6c4b7cd191775a17d951935c7f9927f691f70`; [Wiki #15](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/wiki/pull/15) merged as `7b7d15120e289ab2798476afaf928f6a567c6172`; and [status follow-up #51](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/51) merged as `c53f704202a6e8db150b9c77c761abfad54b5502`. The website, repository documentation, organization profile/registry, seven-public-repository Wiki snapshot, and privacy corrections for Liberated Intelligence and Liberation Mass are published. Unreviewed applicant exercises remain on `review/work-samples-2026-10-23` outside this release. Research, licensing, governance, and private-Wiki changes were not adopted by the batch. | | [x] | P1-06 | done | Repair the 15 existing reader-check failures: correct one relative link and connect fourteen existing T-003 supporting records from their current open-questions section. The checker now passes all 238 Markdown files. Paper findings, author review, and the independent-comparison boundary remain unchanged. | | [ ] | P1-12 | in progress | Initial triage covers the 32-PR starting inventory; private findings remain in a private handoff. Published source for organization #13/#5, Wiki #12, and root #41/#43/#40/#42/#44 is verified. Five public commons companions remain previously checked review candidates. Root #45 now incorporates #44 and has completed a bounded source/edition/navigation pass at `12efef65ede19744ed1f43df01cb5ebbc1165e22` (source/edition review), with the later route proposal tracked under P1-13; author, scholarly and cultural review remain pending. See the [Stoned Age checkpoint](AUDIT.md#intelligence-research-published-and-stoned-age-reviewed-2026-10-24). Stewardship/licensing and private implementation reviews remain separate; publication and adoption are individual decisions. | -| [ ] | P1-13 | in progress | Prepare and review the proposed `rootsequence.systems/stonedage/` route in existing [draft #45](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/45), now at `08286d1eff9592ed7e5eb01e05d1510972effe86`. The combined preview reuses the canonical editions, preserves the homepage, and passes 17 publisher tests and 192 local-target checks. Hosting approval remains unset; the release gate blocks deployment. See the [route checkpoint](AUDIT.md#proposed-stoned-age-website-route-2026-10-24). Review and publication remain pending. | +| [ ] | P1-13 | in progress | Prepare and review the proposed `rootsequence.systems/stonedage/` route in existing [draft #45](https://github.com/Root-Sequence/root-sequence/pull/45), now at `2f382c71c1434f1c2ee447656aa5a1dffe2c57ef`. The combined preview reuses the canonical editions, preserves the homepage, and passes 17 publisher tests and 192 local-target checks. The planned address is recorded in the research README/index, with no homepage link. “How Drugs Explain the Universe” is a working provocation, not a separate companion text. Hosting approval remains unset; the release gate blocks deployment. See the [route checkpoint](AUDIT.md#proposed-stoned-age-website-route-2026-10-24). Review and publication remain pending. | ## P2: small applicant work-samples track