Skip to content

[Status 01] InferRSI evolution: initialization → ac702729 (2026-10-20) #41

Open

Description

@Dong1017

First cumulative status snapshot. This is a progress summary, not a new RFC, acceptance decision or execution authorization.

1. Snapshot

  • Repository: InferMatrixLab/InferRSI.
  • Checked: 2026-10-20, 08:38 UTC / 16:38 Shanghai.
  • Edition: first, cumulative snapshot. Covers initialization including the root commit through the inspected main head, not only the latest four PRs.
  • Initialization: d7af684, 2026-10-08 01:34 UTC, chore: initialize repository; verified to have no parent commits and no changed files (empty initialization).
  • Head: ac702729, 2026-10-20 05:05 UTC, feat: read-only store path and knowledge CLI bridge (#32 PR 2) #39.
  • Navigation: changes after initialization through head. The root is empty, so this comparison covers the subsequent repository content; initialization itself is included in the narrative.
  • Bottom line: the repository has evolved from an initialized scaffold into an agent-assisted inference experiment workbench plus a traceable knowledge layer. It is not yet an autonomous optimizer, and delivered interfaces do not establish skill efficacy or universal hardware gains.

2. What changed: the evolution from init

Dates below describe integration into the repository (UTC), not when every underlying experiment or branch implementation occurred. Stages overlap and are grouped by capability rather than presented as a commit dump.

Stage Evolution Human-facing consequence Main evidence
Oct 8–11: initialization and scaffold Repository initialization → portable layout, evidence segments, test/CI conventions and agent entry rules Teams gain a repeatable starting structure; the design is not yet proof of a working optimizer root commit; #4–#7
Oct 14: executable workbench Scaffold/design → CLI experiment execution, supplied benchmark/quality contracts and diffusion knowledge Baseline/candidate comparisons can produce recorded, scoped evidence rather than narrative-only claims #2; architecture and campaign guides
Oct 15–16: broader knowledge and empirical lessons Initial repository experience → multi-engine bilingual knowledge, contribution/dependency/peer relationships and detailed positive/negative Drama3 evidence Agents can find transfer candidates and avoid repeating failed directions; local wins remain separate from service acceptance #9, #11, #13–#22 (evidence PRs within this range)
Oct 16–18: collaboration and KB contracts Informal coordination and content access → Issue-led responsibility, normalized Reader, revision/dependency handling and authorized candidate Store Ownership, exact material identity, update history and acceptance boundaries become explicit; maintained interfaces are renamed InferRSI #21/#23; #17 with #12/#24–#26; rename and scoped-case integration commits
Oct 19: downstream delivery and readiness General workbench/knowledge → engine-delivery scaffold, Drama3 NPU readiness, privacy guidance and Qwen3-TTS source import Teams get handoff contracts and reusable techniques without turning downstream engines into InferRSI runtime dependencies #27/#28, #29, #33/#34, #35/#36
Oct 20: agent-facing usability Python-level normalized knowledge access and mixed entry guidance → three onboarding paths and collect/read/resource CLI with explicit read-only Store access Less custom glue is needed to find and consume selected material; default-output/install/documentation gaps still require correction #32 via #37/#39

The transition is scaffold → executable experiments → sourced knowledge and lessons → explicit ownership/revisions → easier agent access. Automatic planning, patch generation, efficacy-tested skill selection and automatic experience promotion remain outside the established implementation.

3. Architecture delta

Current architecture, established over this cumulative history: an external human/coding agent drives an experiment workbench and a traceable knowledge layer. The latest usability changes extend access to that architecture rather than replacing it.

flowchart TB
    A["Human / external coding agent: goals, diagnosis, patches, permissions"]
    A --> K["Knowledge: package / checkout / candidate store"]
    A --> W["CLI + RunSpec"]
    W --> H["Harness: AB/BA, deadlines, evidence, verdicts"]
    H --> M["Model: requests, metrics, quality contracts"]
    H --> I["Infra: sources, devices, processes, artifacts"]
    M --> I
    I --> R["Prepared benchmark / validator / independent engine"]
    H --> E["Recorded evidence and reports"]
    E -. "Reviewed lessons; separately authorized updates" .-> K
Loading
  • Evolution across this first edition: the scaffold acquired a concrete Harness/Model/Infra execution path and then a normalized package/checkout/store knowledge surface. The latest step added the knowledge CLI and read-only Store path.
  • Current responsibility boundary: the external agent plans and changes code; shared Harness/Model/Infra modules execute and adjudicate supplied experiments. The dashed feedback path is not an automatic learning or promotion loop.
  • Retained: Reference Matrix for sources and SearchSpace Matrix for resource × stage coverage. Neither is an automatic task router.
  • Ownership: engines keep their runtime in their own repositories. Store Create/Update remain Python APIs for authorized candidates, not edits to package/checkout content.

See the architecture source of truth, rather than duplicating its full module inventory here.

4. Capability status

Delivery, acceptance and validation are deliberately separate.

Capability / workstream In main? Goal acceptance / tracking What is actually validated?
KB v1 / collaboration / Drama3 NPU readiness Yes, delivered within this cumulative history #17, #21, #27 closed Their scoped contracts and recorded checks; NPU readiness is not a working NPU engine
Engine-delivery scaffold Yes, delivered Oct 19 #29 open; acceptance remains to be reconciled Scaffold/recipe checks, not an engine deployment
Privacy guidance Yes, #34 #33 open Rules delivered; no claim that historical/downstream leaks are remediated
Qwen3-TTS knowledge import Yes, #36 #35 open Source/import evidence; performance remains INCONCLUSIVE
Agent Usability v1 Yes, #37/#39 #32 closed, but post-closure review found gaps below PR-head CI passed; clean-install/default-output acceptance is incomplete
Campaign Plan No merged #31 #30/#31 open Proposed template, not an integrated capability
MLX discovery and knowledge No landed support confirmed #38 open Branch-reported checks do not establish main support or Apple Silicon inference readiness
Skill Eval v1 No #40 proposed No pilot result; client, tasks, verifier and authorized budget remain to be settled

5. Evidence and limitations

Current usability gaps

Static review of ac702729 found three bounded problems:

  1. Text-mode collect drops --material content and may emit nothing for query-only no-match; full JSON preserves the envelope.
  2. Checkout quickstart commands need the skills extra/PyYAML, which the base installation step does not supply.
  3. The operation guide misstates legacy search no-match, mandatory context filters and mandatory resource revision.

These require a small corrective change and tests, not a Reader/Store redesign. A local-agent instruction has been prepared; no corrective implementation or PR is confirmed in this snapshot.

Refs: material output finding, install finding, operation-guide findings, successful PR-head CI.

Recorded performance outcomes across the cumulative history

  • Qwen-Image B300: historical scoped accepted result, 30.60% lower latency with 44/44 pixel-identical checks; included as historical evidence, not newly reproduced for this report. Acceptance: Qwen-Image-2.1-Turbo / B300×4 campaign #3 remaining open does not negate the recorded result.
  • Drama3 B300: per-concurrency target remains INCONCLUSIVE; optimization is recorded as paused. Local kernel/graph gains are not service acceptance.
  • Qwen3-TTS import: source-grounded transfer candidates, not accelerator/audio-quality reproduction or per-feature speedup proof.

Recorded campaign results and conditions. This brief uses repository evidence and source inspection; it did not run new benchmarks or independently rerun the full test suite.

6. Next decisions

  1. Usability acceptance: complete a bounded correction for [RFC] Agent Usability v1: onboarding, knowledge discovery and interface alignment #32, test clean installation and text/JSON outputs, then update acceptance evidence against the final revision.
  2. Campaign structure: resolve [RFC] Iteration Campaign Plan: one table for model, hardware, goal, search plan and test plan #30/docs: add a campaign plan template for the plan evidence segment #31, keeping plans linked to the existing matrices and allowing justified, budgeted diagnostics.
  3. Skill efficacy: refine [RFC] Skill Eval v1: revision-scoped discovery and task-efficacy evaluation #40's initial client, tasks/verifier, held-out split and budget before authorizing execution.

Separately, reconcile the already-landed deliverables in #29/#33/#35 with their owners' acceptance criteria. Do not close them solely because a commit merged. MLX remains a parallel, independently scoped workstream.

Activity

  1. added
    kind:statusPeriodic status snapshot
    area:processRepo-wide process, governance, privacy and security rules
    on Oct 21, 2026
  2. Dong1017 commented on Oct 23, 2026

    @Dong1017
    CollaboratorAuthor

    Status 02 — 2026-10-23 published: ac70272978965f0043dcc2ead81afb813c69f63c → 48e0d5894117be7c57f8b4ce793c0ec986f219e8 (38 commits). Covers packaged knowledge, admission/reliability, accepted pilot and newly merged local skill comparisons; PR automation and operational acceptance remain separate. This inspected main head is the base for the next edition.

  3. Dong1017 commented on Oct 31, 2026

    @Dong1017
    CollaboratorAuthor

    Status 03 — 2026-10-31 catch-up for 2026-10-30 published: 48e0d5894117be7c57f8b4ce793c0ec986f219e8 → 6810870046b4f493d39b6eaede0f1a4004369235 (113 commits). Consolidates the prior in-week updates and current acceptance/evidence limits. Actual seven-day comment window: [2026-10-31 14:40:09, 2026-11-07 14:40:09) Asia/Shanghai; no backdated publication. This body SHA is the next edition's baseline.

  4. Dong1017 commented on Nov 6, 2026

    @Dong1017
    CollaboratorAuthor

    Status 04 — 2026-11-06 published. Main 6810870046b4f493d39b6eaede0f1a4004369235 → 1246348f252dbc7e473efb1752c2d81da15e23fd (31 commits). Comment window [2026-11-06 19:12:55, 2026-11-13 19:12:55) Asia/Shanghai.

  5. Dong1017 commented on Nov 8, 2026

    @Dong1017
    CollaboratorAuthor

    Status 04 — consolidated in-week update, 2026-11-08: 1246348f252dbc7e473efb1752c2d81da15e23fd → 3a67f2456156f1071d4821e172a5bb55393f3f08 (one commit). Covers merged DSH source, v0.1.5 publication, the recorded architecture decision and scoped downstream campaign evidence; full host acceptance and the C1/C16 target remain open. One current catch-up, not backdated daily reports.

  6. Dong1017 commented on Nov 9, 2026

    @Dong1017
    CollaboratorAuthor

    The "Publication convention" and "Reusable template" sections have moved to #61 Roadmap, "Status reporting", per the owner's decision. #61 is now the report index and template entry point; new edition index comments go there.

    This issue keeps the Status 01 snapshot and the existing index comments for editions 02–04 unchanged. The moved text is identical apart from two references: "add a short index comment here" now reads "on this issue" (#61), and the sentence "Historical snapshot content above is unchanged" was dropped because it referred to this body.

    The previous body of this issue is preserved in the issue edit history.

  7. zengchuang-hw commented on Nov 17, 2026

    @zengchuang-hw
    Contributor

    #41 历史累计快照独立检视。

    本次只核对声明的历史范围和少量实际代码,不读取报告观点来证明报告自身,也不将 next decisions 转为任务。不恢复任何日报/周报、监控或旧工作,不承诺实施、验收或关闭。

    可独立核实的历史事实:

    • 起点 d7af68416f507c3fc0eac546e53a43a5b43dacdc 的 commit 元数据没有 parent;committer timestamp 为 2026-10-08 01:34:36 UTC。
    • 终点 ac70272978965f0043dcc2ead81afb813c69f63c 的 parent 为 d40f1f193849d67343d656a63ce9c898e4963ae1,committer timestamp 为 2026-10-20 05:05:00 UTC。它早于声明的 08:38 UTC 报告时刻;这不证明该报告在当时实际发布或内容完整。
    • 两点 compare 返回 merge base 等于起点、ahead 36 / behind 0、36 条 commit 元数据。这支持两点的祖先关系和区间规模,不证明每个阶段的验收。
    • 终点 recursive tree 返回 544 个 blob,truncated=false;compare 响应只有 300 个 changed-file 条目。因此不能把这一份 compare 文件列表当作完整文件覆盖证据。起点 tree 的直接读取返回 404;本次不将它包装成已成功读取的树清单。
    • 本次现状参照 main 为 61303fa8150472dfbda62ec8d77908bc05c73f3b,但后续实现不能倒填成历史终点已具备的能力。

    在历史终点直接检查的代码边界:

    1. execution.py 将 run_experiment 委托给 harness runner,并注入 external execution 与 repository_identity。它说明该入口的实际委托关系;不能单凭 facade 名称宣称完整平台或自主优化已实现。
    2. external.execute_trial 调用已有 command executor,读取 result 并保存 execution record;metric 解析失败记录为 metric_error。这个入口自身不是独立任务正确性/性能验收。
    3. model/protocols/metrics.py 的 read_metric 要求存在、数值、非 bool、有限且正值。针对该历史源码做了 9 项 CPU 边界检查,全部通过:合法正数,以及 bool、零、负数、NaN、infinity、字符串、None、缺字段的拒绝路径。它只证明该解析规则,不能验证计时真实性、质量门槛或性能提升。
    4. evidence_paths.py 定义并创建 plan/results/patch/validator 目录。目录存在不意味着资料齐全、源链接可解析或实验已 PASS。

    限制与判定:本次没有逐 commit 重建能力首次引入时间,也没有逐项审计原报告、全部 544 个文件、实验原始数据、CI 或接受决定。因此不宣称累计状态表准确/完整,也不将代码交付等同目标接受或经验性验证。没有可提取的原始任务 AC,故不存在据此宣告整体完成的基础。

    检查使用 metadata 白名单和去注释/docstring 的 Python 视图;未读取 commit messages、其他讨论或报告中的结果/整改观点。没有修改代码、运行模型/设备、合并、启动调度或执行历史建议。

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    area:processRepo-wide process, governance, privacy and security ruleskind:statusPeriodic status snapshot

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions