Repository navigation
Description
What happened
Every time I click T3 Code (Beta) → Check for Updates… in the macOS menu bar, nothing happens. No dialog, no toast, no indication the check ran — "as if that menu item has onClick=noop". I installed the app a few days ago and have tried it several times; it never did anything.
Diagnosis
The menu action is not a no-op: the check runs and succeeds, it just finds an update, and the menu handler has no feedback for that outcome.
checkForUpdatesFromMenu only shows a dialog for two of the update states:
t3code/apps/desktop/src/window/DesktopApplicationMenu.ts
Lines 67 to 89 in 86d8838
| const checkForUpdatesFromMenu = Effect.gen(function* () { | |
| const updates = yield* DesktopUpdates.DesktopUpdates; | |
| const electronDialog = yield* ElectronDialog.ElectronDialog; | |
| const result = yield* updates.check("menu"); | |
| const updateState = result.state; | |
| if (updateState.status === "up-to-date") { | |
| yield* electronDialog.showMessageBox({ | |
| type: "info", | |
| title: "You're up to date!", | |
| message: `T3 Code ${updateState.currentVersion} is currently the newest version available.`, | |
| buttons: ["OK"], | |
| }); | |
| } else if (updateState.status === "error") { | |
| yield* electronDialog.showMessageBox({ | |
| type: "warning", | |
| title: "Update check failed", | |
| message: "Could not check for updates.", | |
| detail: updateState.message ?? "An unknown error occurred. Please try again later.", | |
| buttons: ["OK"], | |
| }); | |
| } | |
| }).pipe(Effect.withSpan("desktop.menu.checkForUpdates")); |
up-to-date→ "You're up to date!"error→ "Update check failed"available(anddownloading/downloaded) → nothing
Because the updater runs with auto-download off (setAutoDownload(false) in apps/desktop/src/updates/DesktopUpdates.ts), finding an update does not start anything either, so from the user's side the click does nothing at all.
This is the gap left by #955 (fix for #954), which shipped in v0.0.11 and added only the up-to-date and error branches. The handler is unchanged on v0.1.5, v0.1.7 and current main (86d8838), so it is not fixed in a newer release. Anyone on a stable build while a newer one exists hits this every time — here, every check since v0.1.6 shipped (2026-10-31) returned available.
Expected: when the check finds an update, the menu action should say so, e.g. a dialog "T3 Code 0.1.7 is available" with Download / Later, or opening Settings → About where the update UI lives. Same for downloading / downloaded.
Steps to reproduce
- Install a desktop build older than the latest release on macOS (here: T3 Code (Beta) 0.1.5 while 0.1.7 is out).
- Click T3 Code (Beta) → Check for Updates… in the menu bar.
- Nothing is shown. The desktop trace records the check and
update available, version: 0.1.7.
Version
0.1.5 (desktop app, T3 Code (Beta), stable channel). Handler confirmed unchanged on v0.1.7 and main @ 86d8838
Environment
macOS 26.6.2 (Darwin 25.6.0), Apple Silicon (arm64), desktop app with its bundled local server 0.1.5
Evidence
# desktop.trace.ndjson — menu click at 2026-11-06 11:59:25 local (spans condensed)
desktop.menu.action exit=Success
desktop.menu.handleCheckForUpdatesClick exit=Success
desktop.menu.checkForUpdates exit=Success durationMs=1210
desktop.updates.check reason=menu exit=Success
desktop.updates.checkForUpdates reason=menu "checking for updates"
desktop.updates.handleCheckingForUpdate "looking for updates"
desktop.updates.applyUpdateAvailable "update available" version=0.1.7
# no dialog shown; no desktop-menu error logged
# all 4 menu-triggered checks in the retained traces (2026-11-03 x2, 11-04, 11-06)
# resolved to applyUpdateAvailable within ~1s; none to up-to-date or errorRelated issues
#954 / #955 — closed; fixed the up-to-date and error cases only. This issue is the remaining "update available" case, still present on main.
Fix applied or workaround
None applied; nothing was changed on the machine. Installing the update through the in-app update UI is the expected path.
Filed by
Claude Code (claude-opus-5-5) via t3 triage
Activity
shivamhwp commentedon Nov 7, 2026
Julius has taken this over in #31957, whose closing reference targets this issue. At main d5fc29f, DesktopApplicationMenu still only shows feedback for up-to-date and error, matching the reported silent available/downloading/downloaded outcomes. No runtime verification was performed in this thread. Stopping this issue-watch job to avoid duplicate work.